[LTD Hell] Liomuald, four5six - take 3

[Mysteriousdewd]

Link to previous BRQ:

viewtopic.php?f=8&t=111345


I am going to point out the exact rules here since it seems some of the mods do not understand their own rules @bezdak

FROM THE VOTEKICK SECTION: http://wiki.entgaming.net/index.php?tit ... ng:VKRules

When you initiate a !votekick, you should clearly explain "Who" and "How" the violator is game ruining via all chat.

If a votekick is initiated to kick a visible game ruiner, all players are obligated to !yes

I am sorry @bezdak COULD YOU PLEASE explain how I ghosted when your rules on YOUR community wiki states i must provide a reason when initiating a votekick. Also how was the votekick unjustified? You clearly did not read any of my posts or the game log as he CLEARLY STATES RIGHT HERE THAT HE PLANS ON GRIEFING THE GAME:

Right here he clearly says he plans on staying 6/2 because i asked him to solo send to which how can you not take what he is saying as pure and undeniable proof is beyond my understanding of you.

(05:06 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: blue don't solo send
(05:12 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: with your elo you know the rules of ent
(05:36 / Allied) Liomuald: now i stay 6/2 until 10
(05:42 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: why?
(05:51 / Allied) Liomuald: why not
(05:57 / Allied) Liomuald: throw some rules at me
(05:58 / Allied) Liomuald: or play
(06:00 / Allied) katsch2222: he is trolling... just let him be.. he has no life
(06:00 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: you have 200 gold
(06:01 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: build
(06:05 / Allied) Liomuald: no am not
(06:06 / Allied) Liomuald: fuck of
(06:12 / Allied) Mysteriousdewd: you are clearly trolling

So please read the chat logs I have provided and the chat logs once more because I don't believe you even looked at the replay. His ELO which if you took the time to look up as I stated a player with how much he has and if you check his stats with how many games he has played on the bots in general should:

A: know how to play
B: know the ent rules

And what about orange? This was not only directed at one person if you read my post which you clearly didn't @Bezdak orange purposely refuses to votekick which is against the rules DESPITE HIS OWN TEAM SAYING THAT BLUE WHO IS LIOMUALD IS TROLLING.

I saw from his roll at lvl 1 he wasn't familiar with landmines yes, but even after leaking for several rounds he did nothing to fix it. Stopped lumbering. As well as lied and blatantly trolled in the chat. How did I bully him? I simply followed your rules at first and he chose to lie to the other team and flame me at any chance he got.

I don't think you are lazy, I think you don't even understand your own communities rules.

[Mysteriousdewd]

Also @bezdak please read the ban request here about Liomuald: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=111349&p=437351&hilit=liomuald#p437351

And tell me that he doesn't know what he is doing. Please. Find at least 1 thing that shows me that he isn't a troll. JUST 1 THING!

Edit: Just to throw this in here yes my initial point against @jabba41 was about how i felt he was lazy and skimmed through my request despite my view that i provided enough indication of the times in my original request. He gave me the chance to provide better proof.

As you can see from the request in this post here: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=111349&p=437351&hilit=liomuald#p437351

I gave @jabba41 the exact examples of when liomuald griefed. I understand that this is a voluntary position you hold but when someone else who is dealing with a request comes in and asks me to give more evidence and then you come in with almost little to no understanding of the situation is not cool.

I would like @jabba41 or another mod to evaluate both of these claims and come to an unbiased opinion on this request as liomuald clearly is trolling but @bezdak does not seem to understand what trolling is.

[bezdak]

Again - I've watched the whole 27 minutes replay and read the whole chat log afterwards again to write down my findings accurately.
As I have already said - the fact that you are 9/4 and 9/5 is absolutely irrelevant in case of someone else game ruining and it is a pure ghosting, nothing else. Also you seem to not understand the fact he simply did not break any rules.

Spoiler!

It is possible to game ruin by being new. In this case, votekick will only be valid if the new player refuses to learn and cooperate. Just because someone is a newbie or bad does not mean he is intentionally game ruining.

You did absolutely nothing to help him, did not give any advice whatsoever, therefore you cannot say he refused to cooperate.

At this point you are only wasting our time. Please, take it as it is, you've already got your BRQ reviewed by 2 different mods with the same exact result.

Ban request denied.

Processing.