[DOTA] [nadia @uswest]

[monkeyrush]

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 326439.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA apem us/ca #96
Your Warcraft III Username: monkeyrush
Violator's Warcraft III Username: nadia
Violated Rule(s): not helping team, didnt defend at all at an important point of game (57.00), essentially throwing
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): first time: 35.30 other team pushing bot to base tower, instead Nadia goes solo pushing top lane
Any further thoughts:
all times are in-game time
43.00 we say to push mid or bot to rax, Nadia leaves team to solo push top again
45.00 our whole team went back, Nadia still pushes solo top
47.30 we are pushing mid to rax, Nadia instead neutralling
49.15 Karma even says to Nadia that he is never with us
56.05 Nadia again solo pushes mid
56.17 Karma again says Nadia never comes with us
57.36 ursa respawns and goes afk, at an important point of the game as the scourge were hard pushing base mid for rax
he continues to run around, not defend, stand around, attack creeps instead

Nadia makes no communication with team, after about 35.00 he does his own thing solo.

[BeerLord]

So, after min 35 or so:
3940: team fight bottom lane ursa pushes top lane solo
4539: team fight mid, ursa comes to help.
4704: 3 go rax top ursa goes bot to try and save tower, but top was raxed successfully without him.
4900: team fight sentinel woods while ursa was dead.
5035: team raxing mid while ursa in woods, but mid was raxed successfully without him.
5400: ursa roshes with team.
5415: ursa joins team fight.
5825: team fight top lane but ursa is dead.
6016: ursa respawns while scourge pushing mid to rax. 2 allies are dead, omni is near dead and at fountain healing. Mortred dies at 6020. Ursa remains at fountain until 6046. He comes out to help ogre, but as he moves to help ogre gets caught in voids ult so ursa has no choice but to hit creeps or back.

I see nothing ban worthy here. The team fight bot he missed you guys basically won. The rax attempts he missed were successful without him. And there were many examples of when he was with his team. Two team fights he missed because he was dead. The end was unfortunate timing with respect to allied deaths, and the 30 second afk had no effect since 3 allies were dead and there was nothing he could have done at the time except die.
Denied.