Page 1 of 1

[LTD] picketingcarl

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2015 1:21 am
by Tedro32
Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 056724.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] Legion TD 3.5 Beta #1
Your Warcraft III Username: Tedro32
Violator's Warcraft III Username: picketingcarl
Violated Rule(s): wrong mode
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): 00:04
Any further thoughts: he waited to be near countdown to send mode.

Lobby chat

[picketingcarl]: sdgmcbLI
[System]: Waiting to start until players have been pinged: Akasya
[picketingcarl]: sdgmcbLI
[System]: Waiting to start until players have been pinged: Akasya
[razre]: li?
[picketingcarl]: ya
[TomRiddle]: no li
[picketingcarl]: no cross
[System]: 10. . .
[System]: 9. . .
[System]: 8. . .
[System]: 7. . .
[System]: 6. . .
[picketingcarl]: li
[System]: 5. . .
[System]: 4. . .
[System]: 3. . .
[System]: 2. . .
[System]: 1. . .

In game mode:

(00:00 / All) AvadaKedavra: Good luck and have fun!
(00:02 / Allied) Akasya: - zoom 150
(00:04 / Allied) picketingcarl: -sdgmcbli
(00:06 / Allied) Akasya: -zoom 150
(01:00 / All) TomRiddle: red your going to be reported for not saying the mode until countdown

Re: [LTD] picketingcarl

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2015 1:23 pm
by Patti30
"When using a mode other than the default one (-hpgmcb prophet), the host (red) has to announce it in the lobby before the game starts. Every player must be informed, so they have the opportunity to leave in case of dislike."
I believe as long as you inform the players before the countdown it is ok.

Re: [LTD] picketingcarl

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2015 1:41 pm
by MichaelSong
I downloaded and read all the lobby chat.

[picketingcarl]: sdgmcbLI
[System]: Waiting to start until players have been pinged: Akasya
[picketingcarl]: sdgmcbLI
[System]: Waiting to start until players have been pinged: Akasya
[razre]: li?
[picketingcarl]: ya
[TomRiddle]: no li
[picketingcarl]: no cross
[System]: 10. . .
[System]: 9. . .
[System]: 8. . .
[System]: 7. . .
[System]: 6. . .
[picketingcarl]: li
[System]: 5. . .
[System]: 4. . .
[System]: 3. . .
[System]: 2. . .
[System]: 1. . .

As, Ent rules say (@patti30 mentioned earlier)
"When using a mode other than the default one (-hpgmcb prophet), the host (red) has to announce it in the lobby before the game starts. Every player must be informed, so they have the opportunity to leave in case of dislike."

picketingcarl has informed the mode before even countdown starts, which means you had enough time to exit the game.
The only problem is he/she typed li mode in captial letter, so he/she was typed again to make it clear.

In my opinion, this request will be denied from enough evidance

@Tedro32 there are enough denied ban requests, if you're informed before countdown. I would recommend in next time, try to exit the game when countdown started. if you don't dislike the mode.

Re: [LTD] picketingcarl

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2015 4:10 pm
by Tedro32
@michaelsong and @patti30 thanks both for answering and i do agree with both mostly with patti30. And i wanted you to know,i havent been playing ltd for too long and in other maps i am used to know game mode at the moment someone has taken red place. However, in this case seems red didnt break rules.

Re: [LTD] picketingcarl

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2015 8:27 pm
by matdas
denied. mode was announced with ample time before countdown