[BS] eseapel@useast & tyzzy@useast

[Lipton]

Replay Link:
1. http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 825338.w3g
2. http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 821105.w3g
Game Name:
1. [ENT] Battleships Pro 5v5 #54
2. [ENT] Battleships Pro 5v5 #37
Your Warcraft III Username: rotlatla
Violator's Warcraft III Username: eseapel@useast & tyzzy@useast
Violated Rule(s): pooling & afk & trolling for ruin the game
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): reference as below report
Any further thoughts:

1. eseapel@useast (aka AYAL & i_eat_koreans)
he played this game(http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 821105.w3g)
and this guy aka AYAL was afk from start to leave. before the left, he did pooling to tyzzy by item. (around 6:50)
im expecting to excuse from him "it was not pooling via item burning"
yes, it was not. but "Only the Trader Ship can pool gold." by ENT rules.
item is same, only acceptable "Burning your own items"
item pooling issued already many time make trouble on BS games.
pooling should be abolished.

also, he played this game(http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 825338.w3g)
he was eseapel, played for ruin the game.
8:50 he could survive, but didnt run away.
around 12:00 ~ 16:00 didnt do anything defense or fight. even sold all item at that time for loosing gold.
certainly, he will say he is newbie of this game. I dont think so.
he aka i_eat_koreans. if you check the any game of him, you can recognize his trolling.
but, if he still say newbie, i can teach for him some BS skills

anyway, he did afk & gold pooling for abuse.


2. tyzzy@useast (aka batman)
this guy is really terrible. he also played this game.(http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 821105.w3g)
item pooling with AYAL. he looks like first game after banned.
he already got banned many times.
(https://entgaming.net/forum/viewtopic.p ... 0&p=286768)
(https://entgaming.net/forum/viewtopic.p ... zy#p290798)
also, he exactly knows what he did from here
(https://entgaming.net/forum/viewtopic.p ... zy#p294870)
i think he needs more heavy penalty.

another one,
(http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 632726.w3g)
in this game, he did troll for ruin the game.
2:25, 5:38, 8:10, 11:08 etc... keep try to die calculatedly during whole the game.
actually, dont need time point, anybody recognize his trolling play.
he also has many typing for make excuse. that was too childish...
especially at around 16:45 he did his best for die
around 53:00 he make away for enemies attack.
and he didnt do anything from that time just hide.
he has enough gold for weapon but played without weapon until 58:00. it was 62mins game lol.
is that make a sense? he just needs time for make sure to lose.
after weapon, he still doesnt have any drive to fight.
keep going fail to attack and defence.

he also not a newbie. he's got over 2500elo (aka ponm) and ranked 2nd on Battleships Pro game before stats reset.
I don't know why he tried to trolling.
but, one of interest things you can see aka i_eat_koreans on the other team
I have no idea, what they do. will let admins to decide it.
even though they got trolling, almost lost the game already.
possibly they are real newbie thought

lately, BS player is on the decrease.
their behavior is very harmful to other good player.
please make sure penalty to that guys.
thanks.

[oh7i]

Fully aware of the rule "Do not go away from keyboard for an excessive amount of time, especially without telling other players beforehand, and/or refuse to play the game in an attempt to ruin it. Neither are you allowed to grief by resetting the afk timer."
I simply couldn't stay to play the game after it started so I came back to quit the game in order to fallow the rules, and left an item to try to make it up for team.
(05:15 / Allied) AYAL: i need to go
(05:18 / Allied) AYAL: come
(05:44 / Allied) tyzzy: no
(05:47 / Allied) tyzzy: just leave
(06:46 / Allied) AYAL: peace
Also aware of the rule "Do not pool teammates via burning." however the rule is the way it is now, and I will be happy to fallow the new rules if admins decide to change them.
https://entgaming.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=43&t=39663
Just because the game didn't go the way as you hoped, it doesn't mean your team is trolling you, sometimes you just need to try harder, by all means lol.

[Jabba41]

--------------------http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 825338.w3g - First replay-----------------------------------

eseapel@useast
-> Dont see evidence of intentional game ruining. He could indeed have survived but mistakes happen and he dont look like a very skilled player that's why he was so long in base picking a new ship and he sold his items to get other canons /hulls.



--------------http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 821105.w3g- second replay ------------------

eseapel@useast
-> He already claimed his Point. No need to ban him after he already said he had to go.
--> Warned for pooling, even when he had good intentions.


tyzzy@useast
-> Just picked up the leavers item, didnt sold it or anything and they dont intentional pool

ayal@useast.battle.net

Code: Select all

  6:43 <AYAL> 0x13: Target+object order: dropitem (X: -390.76, Y: 6082.77, Object: 0x0006203500005692, flags: 0x0044)

+ AFk first 6 minuts into the game then bought chaos canon and quit
-> Banned 3 days


-------------http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 632726.w3g - third replay --------------------

-> Repost again, he's not in that game and I_eat_koreans isnt listed as his alias.