2nd opinion

[Energizer]

Replay Link: https://entgaming.net/replay.php?id=9494556
Game Name: [ENT] NWU -sdsm #53
Your Warcraft III Username: energizer
Violator's Warcraft III Username: crooked
Violated Rule(s): left game b4 was over
Time of Violation (in-game or replay):
2m29s
Any further thoughts:

(02:09 / All) Crooked: alright boys
(02:11 / All) LAO)G(DZHI-DZHI: Crooked has left the game voluntarily.
(02:11 / QUIT) Crooked: Left

game ended at 28 min mark
-------------------------------------
Case 1: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=112639&p=441598&hilit=nwu#p441598
Case 2: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=112296&p=440614&hilit=nwu#p440614

While case 2 is a little different it still counts. The NWU bots do not ban people for leaving a game otherwise I would not put the ban request up. This player deliberately left the game at the 2 minute mark when the game was nowhere near over. He clearly left because he wanted to try and get a draw or simply b/c he did not want to play.

This was the mods decision in the original br: "Auto ban handles leavers/disconnections/rage quits/etc. You don't have to report them, unless they make a habbit ouf of it, which was not the case."

So we should not report players unless they make a habit of breaking the rules. The player left the game two minutes after it began for no reason, he did not dc or get dropped or vk'd. The player must be banned the same 3 days that the person in case 1 was. If you, ent staff, want us NWU people to stop reporting leavers then fix the bots so they ban those who leave. Otherwise, this player and others will need to be manually banned for leaving. If this not reporting unless making a habit out of something starts to become precedent then there are some clear flaws in the ENT rules and then they should make sure that is incorporated into the rules "do not report players unless they make a habit of breaking the rules, a couple of times is okay"

[FalenGa]

Code: Select all

autoban   autoban: left at 149/1719    [ENT] NWU -sdsm #53   2017-06-21 00:00:00   22 Jun 2017 03:47:14 EEST   Expired

He did get banned. And we do not ban people 2 times for 1 violation, unless, as i said in your first request, they make a habbit out of it.

The first case you linked was a user that left more than 1 games in a day.

The 2nd case was a user going afk for 5+ minutes.

Fyi @Energizer

[Energizer]

@falenga

why did you not say so in the ban request I put up then?? this can be processed if he was banned

[FalenGa]

I did, but not in those exact words.

Auto ban handles leavers/disconnections/rage quits/etc.

Anyway, processing.