[DOTA] usamagausa uswest

[SDKev760]

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 562915.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA arem us/ca #28
Your Warcraft III Username: penlslnsert4m0m
Violator's Warcraft III Username: usamagausa
Violated Rule(s): Kick Abuse
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): 17:59, 29:49
Any further thoughts: Tide has been in almost every battle to support them for kills and saved them. USAMAGAusa usually play stack with blue. They're used to playing with noobs.. He votekick tide several time on abuse.

[Unitil]

Below is my personal opinion on the claims above, and what I've found while using DRM and watching the replay.

Vote Kick Abuse

Spoiler!

First Vote-Kick Chat logs:

Code: Select all

16:20    [Allies] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): tide afk
16:27    [Allies] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): !votekick chr
16:27    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has been started by player [USAMAGAUSA]. 7 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
16:27    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Type !yes to vote.
16:27    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
16:29    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): afk
16:31    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): kick him
16:35    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): -afk
16:38    [Allies] fOOdtiME (Anub'seran): !yes
16:38    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [fOOdtiME] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 6 more votes are needed to pass.
16:39    [Allies] Leeroy (King): !yes
16:39    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [Leeroy] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 5 more votes are needed to pass.
16:40    fOOdtiME (Anub'seran) [2-4] has acquired a Double Damage rune
16:40    [Allies] WIJA (Crixalis): probably reading item descriptions
16:41    [Allies] spode (Spectre): -afk
16:41    [Allies] GetSniped (Rubick): -afk
16:42    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): 1yes
16:46    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): !yes
16:46    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [penlslnsert4m0m] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 4 more votes are needed to pass.
16:48    [Allies] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): !ignore get
16:49    USAMAGAUSA has paused the game.
16:49    [All] GetSniped (Rubick): isnt afk
16:49    spode has resumed the game.
16:49    GetSniped has resumed the game.
16:50    [Allies] Topdog (Syllabear): -afk
17:23    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has expired.

Reason Stated for Vote-kick attempt: AFK

Time Spent AFK Up-to vote-kick attempt : In-game timer

• 16:09 ~ 16:20 (Started moving again at 16:38)

Total time AFK prior to report of being "AFK" : 11 Seconds (does not include death)

Opinion: Lied about when a person has been afk.

-------------------------------

Second Vote-Kick Chat logs:

Code: Select all

28:13    [Allies] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): plsd kick tide
28:15    [Allies] Leeroy (King): broken hero
28:17    [Allies] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): !votekick ch
28:17    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has been started by player [USAMAGAUSA]. 7 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
28:17    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Type !yes to vote.
28:17    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
28:22    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): pls kick this feeeder
28:24    USAMAGAUSA has paused the game.
28:24    penlslnsert4m0m has resumed the game.
28:24    GetSniped has resumed the game.
28:24    spode has resumed the game.
28:25    [Allies] fOOdtiME (Anub'seran): !
28:26    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): kick the ruiner
28:28    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): votekick abuse
28:29    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): banning
28:32    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): bullsghit
28:36    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): hhes 10-8\
28:44    fOOdtiME (Anub'seran) [5-6] was been killed by Clan.Y (Slark) [15-2]. Assist: GetSniped (Rubick) [9-3]
28:44    Clan.Y (Slark) [15-2] is wicked sick!!
28:47    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): u stack all day long
28:50    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): in every game
28:53    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): stop crying
29:11    Sentinel bottom level 2 tower was destroyed by The Scourge.
29:14    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has expired.

Reason Stated for Vote-kick attempt: Game Ruin

Score of:
Chrisco (Tidehunter), level 8, KDA: 1-7-0

Opinion: It did not appear like Chrisco was attempting to feed during the game, up to the votekick being initiated. He was roaming, and moving with the team as necessary, however, got caught out in a few unfortunate circumstances.

-------------------------------

Third Vote Kick Attempt:

Code: Select all

50:32    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): now hes trolling
50:36    [Allies] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): !votekick ch
50:36    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has been started by player [USAMAGAUSA]. 7 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
50:36    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Type !yes to vote.
50:36    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
50:38    USAMAGAUSA has paused the game.
50:38    [Allies] Leeroy (King): !yes
50:38    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [Leeroy] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 6 more votes are needed to pass.
50:38    spode has resumed the game.
50:39    [Allies] GetSniped (Rubick): !yes
50:39    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [GetSniped] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 5 more votes are needed to pass.
50:39    [Allies] fOOdtiME (Anub'seran): !yes
50:39    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [fOOdtiME] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 4 more votes are needed to pass.
50:41    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): fuckn kick this noob a;lrdy
50:41    [Allies] WIJA (Crixalis): !yes
50:41    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [WIJA] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 3 more votes are needed to pass.
50:41    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): 3 attempt
50:43    [Allies] Topdog (Syllabear): !yes
50:43    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [Topdog] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 2 more votes are needed to pass.
50:46    [Allies] spode (Spectre): !yes
50:46    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): Player [spode] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 1 more votes are needed to pass.
50:53    Topdog (Syllabear) [2-4] has acquired a Haste rune
50:56    [All] USAMAGAUSA (Rhasta): well kick phioe next

51:32    [All] penlslnsert4m0m (Phoenix): tide save u guys many times
51:33    [All] Topdog (Syllabear): A votekick against player [Chrisco] has expired.

Reason Stated for Vote-kick attempt: Trolling

Score of:
Chrisco (Tidehunter), level 15, KDA: 2-11-6

Opinion: Same opinion as the last vote-kick attempt. Did not appear like he was trolling his team mate at all.

-------------------------------

Fourth Vote Kick Attempt:

Code: Select all

(52:08 / Allied) USAMAGAUSA: !votekick ch
(52:08 / All) Topdog: A votekick against player [Chrisco] has been started by player [USAMAGAUSA]. 7 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(52:08 / All) Topdog: Type !yes to vote.
(52:08 / All) Topdog: ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
(52:10 / Allied) Leeroy: !yes
(52:10 / All) Topdog: Player [Leeroy] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 6 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:10 / Allied) GetSniped: !yes
(52:10 / All) Topdog: Player [GetSniped] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 5 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:10 / Allied) fOOdtiME: !yes
(52:10 / All) Topdog: Player [fOOdtiME] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 4 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:12 / All) USAMAGAUSA: fuckn kick this noob a;lrdy
(52:12 / Allied) WIJA: !yes
(52:12 / All) Topdog: Player [WIJA] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 3 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:12 / All) penlslnsert4m0m: 3 attempt
(52:15 / Allied) Topdog: !yes
(52:15 / All) Topdog: Player [Topdog] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 2 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:18 / Allied) spode: !yes
(52:18 / All) Topdog: Player [spode] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 1 more votes are needed to pass.
(52:28 / All) USAMAGAUSA: well kick phioe next
(53:03 / All) penlslnsert4m0m: tide save u guys many times
(53:05 / All) Topdog: A votekick against player [Chrisco] has expired.

Reason Stated for Vote-kick attempt: Being a Noob

Game Record:
Games: 84
Win/Loss: 25/59 (29.76%)
KDR: 0.3:1

Opinion: Player does not appear to be the best, however, not an excuse to kick someone who is not purposefully trying to break ENT Gaming rules.

-------------------------------

Fifth Vote Kick Attempt:

Code: Select all

(53:49 / Allied) GetSniped: !votekick chrisco
(53:49 / All) Topdog: A votekick against player [Chrisco] has been started by player [GetSniped]. 7 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(53:49 / All) Topdog: Type !yes to vote.
(53:49 / All) Topdog: ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
(53:52 / All) USAMAGAUSA: how is it stakjced u fuck noob
(53:54 / Allied) Topdog: -afk
(53:54 / Allied) spode: !yes
(53:54 / All) Topdog: Player [spode] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 6 more votes are needed to pass.
(53:57 / All) USAMAGAUSA: 15/15
(53:59 / All) USAMAGAUSA: u cunt
(53:59 / Allied) WIJA: !yes
(53:59 / All) Topdog: Player [WIJA] voted to kick player [Chrisco]. 5 more votes are needed to pass.
(54:02 / All) penlslnsert4m0m: -afk
(54:16) killed USAMAGAUSA
(54:20 / Allied) Leeroy: why are u there
(54:21 / Allied) Leeroy: whu
(54:22 / Allied) Leeroy: why
(54:25 / Allied) Leeroy: u know u will get jumped
(54:25 / Allied) Leeroy: why
(54:27) Topdog killed WIJA
(54:49 / All) Topdog: A votekick against player [Chrisco] has expired.

Reason Stated for Vote-kick attempt: None

Opinion: No explanation provided for trying to kick Chrisco, however, this was at the very end of the game when the base was being destroyed.

Concluding Thoughts
USAMAGAUSA@USWest.battle.net
Starting random votes for different reasons with no actually evidence is considered Vote Kick Abuse. See reasons above for my opinion on every vote kick attempt made. Though Chrisco may not of had a good score, I saw no intention to break any rules during your votes, and you made up a false accusation of him being AFK.

Rules I believe to be broken during this game:

Code: Select all

• Do not spam or randomly start !votekicks, do not !votekick to avoid being kicked, and do not !votekick without proper reasons. Votekicks are ban-able even if they are not passed since negative intentions can still be assessed and misusing it can lead others to misuse it. Kicks and bans are enforced based on how severe the rule has been violated. ENT keeps the right to enforce punishments as warning.

[Merex]

Nice input @Unitil

Banned.