[HHTD] babow2280@asia.battle.net / c0mmander@europe.battle.net

[raKs]

Replay Link: https://entgaming.net/replay.php?id=10469490
Game Name: [ENT] HELLHALT TD #47
Your Warcraft III Username: raKs
Violator's Warcraft III Username: (Red) babow2280 / (Blue) c0mmander
Violated Rule(s): Red: Refusing/Avoiding to heal. Refusing to cooperate by sending alone and not save-send with teammates to win.
Blue: Game Leaving.
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): Solo Sends lvl 9 and 12. No Team Sends on 10 and 14. Missed Heal on 10. / Blue left after lvl 2.
Any further thoughts: Red (babow2280): No communication at all. Just solo sent on 9 and 12. No Team Sends. Did not Heal on lvl 10.
If Blue (c0mmander) doesnt get a Autobann for Gameleaving pls ban him too for Leaving the Game early.

[Astros]

I am not familiar with how Hell Hall TD games are usually judged in ban requests but I have reviewed what occurred in the game and can offer my opinion.

Blue leaves at level 2. I have noticed leavers of Hell Hall somehow don't get banned while others do. Can anyone confirm what constitutes a leaver ban?

As for red: I checked his HHTD stats and he's 2-11 W/L and from Asia. There may be a language barrier and honestly, he just doesn't seem to know what he's doing; especially with the random units and positioning.

Teal says to up king at level 4, red does. Level 6, he listens to teal and ups again. Teal says to up until 7 and to send on level 10.
Red leaks 8 so he probably felt that he should up the king as it wasn't strong enough to contain the leaks.
At level 10, teal is the only one who sends despite giving red the notice that they will send 10. Red opts to upgrade the king. I don't think this is a large issue as red could have felt at the last moment that the king was too weak and wouldn't hold. Regardless, sending at level 10 was probably a bad call and the king should have been upgraded seeing as they did leak. Red does miss heal at 10 but he was upgrading the king so he may have not realized what was going on. Not sure if it was an intentional miss or an inexperienced player making a mistake. At level 12, red does solo send despite teal saying to send 14.


Overall, my conclusion is that red is just inexperienced and since he's from Asia, there was a language barrier that may have confused him. His W/L record shows his experience level and ability to play the game and considering he's gone months without playing a game, it makes sense for red to make mistakes.
Yes, there were levels where he did listen to teal but others where he didn't. I do not see a valid reason to ban red as he is quite inexperienced.

[Astros]

Denied. Red is a rather inexperienced player but he will be warned.