[LTD] chaky@uswest.battle.net

[James_Gefyrst]

Replay Link: http://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=10538429
Game Name: [ENT] Legion TD Mega #99
Your Warcraft III Username: fistmedaddy@europe.battle.net
Violator's Warcraft III Username: lord_of_danes@europe.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): Did not kick a player from the game who had gone afk for 10 minutes.
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): Around 30:00 (timestamps in replay does only show 00:00)
Any further thoughts:

[James_Gefyrst]

Replay Link: http://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=10538429
Game Name: [ENT] Legion TD Mega #99
Your Warcraft III Username: fistmedaddy@europe.battle.net
Violator's Warcraft III Username: xortron@uswest.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): Did not kick a player from the game who had gone afk for 10 minutes.
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): Around 30:00 (timestamps in replay does only show 00:00)
Any further thoughts:

[James_Gefyrst]

Replay Link: http://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=10538429
Game Name: [ENT] Legion TD Mega #99
Your Warcraft III Username: fistmedaddy@europe.battle.net
Violator's Warcraft III Username: chaky@uswest.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): Had gone AFK for 10 minutes.
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): Around 20:00 (timestamps in replay does only show 00:00)
Any further thoughts:

[Ben_T]

Chaky was afk for about 12 minutes and two votekicks were initiated, but none passed. No one noticed he was afk, even his teammates, however when it became apparent to his teammates that he was afk, they informed the West Legion and initiated a votekick. The game ended on level 14 with a loss for the East Legion due to the heavy leak from Chaky. On level 13, the second votekick was initiated and it should have been obvious to the other team that pink was afk as he was no longer sending any units.

The East Legion let the West Legion know Chaky was afk:

Spoiler!

(00:00 / Allied) FistMeDaddy: Pink is afk
(00:00 / Allied) FistMeDaddy: Lol
(00:00 / Allied) FistMeDaddy: !afk
(00:00 / Allied) UltraProo: !afk
(00:00 / Allied) can_o_crap: oh wow
(00:00 / All) can_o_crap: AFK
(00:00 / All) UltraProo: afk for 10 min lol
(00:00 / All) can_o_crap: !afk
(00:00 / All) can_o_crap: We still have an afk since 10 m
(00:01 / All) UltraProo: kick

The two votekicks initiated:

Spoiler!

(00:00 / Allied) FistMeDaddy: !votekick chaky
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: A votekick against player [chaky] has been started by player [FistMeDaddy]. 4 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Type !yes to vote.
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
(00:00 / Allied) can_o_crap: !yes
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [can_o_crap] voted to kick player [chaky]. 3 more votes are needed to pass.
(00:00 / Allied) UltraProo: !yes
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [UltraProo] voted to kick player [chaky]. 2 more votes are needed to pass.
(00:00 / All) can_o_crap: !afk
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: A votekick against player [chaky] has expired.
(00:00 / Allied) UltraProo: !votekick chaky
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: A votekick against player [chaky] has been started by player [UltraProo]. 4 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Type !yes to vote.
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
(00:00 / Allied) pushadinopmvp: !yes
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [pushadinopmvp] voted to kick player [chaky]. 3 more votes are needed to pass.
(00:00 / All) can_o_crap: !yes
(00:00 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [can_o_crap] voted to kick player [chaky]. 2 more votes are needed to pass.
(00:02 / Allied) CarbonTh1ef: !yes
(00:02 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [CarbonTh1ef] voted to kick player [chaky]. 1 more votes are needed to pass.

Lord_of_danes@europe.battle.net and Xortron@uswest.battle.net did not participate in the votekick and should be banned for not kicking an afk player

Side note: UltraProo@server.eurobattle.net and can_o_crap@server.eurobattle.net saved the game while it was still in progress, this is a poor idea as it can mess people up or cause the game to crash. As there was reasoning behind this, it might be acceptable to give a warning or a minor ban to these to players for an in-game save.

Spoiler!

(00:19 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [UltraProo] is saving the game.
(00:19 / Saving game ?) UltraProo: Save game.
(00:30 / All) Lord_of_danes: Player [can_o_crap] is saving the game.
(00:30 / Saving game ?) can_o_crap: Save game.

Concluding, chaky@uswest.battle.net should be banned for being afk for about 12 minutes, Lord_of_danes@europe.battle.net and Xortron@uswest.battle.net should be banned for not participating in the votekick on the afk player, and possibly ban UltraProo@server.eurobattle.net and can_o_crap@server.eurobattle.net for saving in-game.

[Quetra]

Chaky banned 5 days.

Xorton and Lord_of_danes banned 2 days.

Not worth banning for the save game since they were not doing it for malicious reasons.