[DOTA] Thizz@useast.battle.net

[Emperor]

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 486012.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA arem us/ca #75
Your Warcraft III Username: LordOdin@useast.battle.net
Violator's Warcraft III Username: Thizz@useast.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): Attempt to game ruin - Buys Divine Rapier at end of game
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): 1 hour 12 minute mark
Any further thoughts: So I wouldn't normally submit this but the fact that Mags buys a freaking Divine Rapier when it was the ONE single item that could screw us seeing as though it was 2 lanes down to 2 lanes down just struck me as odd. So odd turned into him rushing out of our bot base SOLO and he winds up dying and feeding DR. Thank god my teammates were smart enough to D hard and get it back while I was hard pushing mid but the fact that Mags decided to buy the freaking 1 item that could totally screw us and goes solo bot and dies is just enough for me to know that he wanted us to lose. He played fine all game but his choice to buy DR and feed solo even though we wound up winning (because I was smart enough to stay top and end it myself) was blatant.

Many thanks,

Emp

[Emperor]

I ask when watching this replay to take into consideration the 1 item a player could buy in order to LOSE a game and then going bot to D solo and dying when all Scourge had to do was take bot rax for the win. There was NO reason for him to buy that item other than he wanted to feed it and have us lose.

[Emperor]

And to be honest if he really wanted to actually win the game he woulda TP'ed mid or top and just flat out won it instead of going solo D bot and feeding the DR.

[Hash]

So after watching the entire replay, I want to start off by saying throughout the whole game I did not see mag intentionally trying to feed the other team in any type of way. He was helping your team get kills, he tried to avoid dying when he was low on hp, so he never really showed intent of trying make your team lose.

1:14:05 Orange has his crow buy a Divine Reaper from the shop.
1:14:20 Only grey is in vision pushing bot, so orange rushes straight at him to defend your team's rax (orange's crow is on the way to his mag, to give his mag the DR), now it was not until AFTER orange had rushed grey, that brown came into vision. So it's not like orange rushed out to go suicide to them, he thought it would just be grey there.
1:14:27 Orange's crow is close to mag, but orange understands he's about to die, as he is dying he sends his crow to the base, away from enemy units so they cannot kill his crow and steal the DR. This action right here looks to me like he did not buy the DR intending to feed it, or else he would have let his crow die, or tried to pass it off to his mag as he was dying.

In your statement you claimed this "So odd turned into him rushing out of our bot base SOLO and he winds up dying and feeding DR. Thank god my teammates were smart enough to D hard and get it back"

This was in fact not true, because he never fed his DR, your enemies never had the DR at any time, it was in possession of his crow, when he died, and after he revived, it was on his mag.

Now considering:

1. Throughout the game he showed no intent of trying to make your team lose.
2. After orange bought his DR, he did not actually feed it to your enemies.
3. Your team won in the end anyways.

I do not think that Thizz should be banned.

[SeriouslyStrange]

As beautifully stated by @Hash.
Denied.