[ID] sarathecow@europe.battle.net

[osug]

Replay Link: https://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=9847874
Game Name: Island Defense #18
Your Warcraft III Username: osug
Violator's Warcraft III Username: sarathecow
Violated Rule(s): intentional Feed
Time of Violation (in-game or replay):
11 Minutes ingame: - mak (sarathecow) feed around 25 fruits intentional.
13 Minutes ingame: - mak feeds again. this time around 30 fruits
Any further thoughts:
- Titan wasn't that good. therefore we gave him xp, fr and gc to make it fair
- Sarathecow didn't asked if we all are fine with feeding. He just did it.
even tho, I told him several times that I am against the feeding.

Spoiler!

(11:31 / Allied) osug: dont feed
(13:03 / Allied) osug: dont feed
(13:08 / Allied) osug: he got fr and xp
(13:24 / Allied) osug: mka stop it
(13:26 / Allied) osug: im against it!
(14:25 / Allied) osug: dont feed
(14:29 / Allied) osug: deto it mak

- Cmac seemed to be the only one to be for the feed
- Mak didn't deto his feed nor did he apologize

[Arcanium]

I have reviewed. There were indeed 2 instances of feeding many fruits which both held under 60% consent of peoples votes, with 3 players opposing feed - Ollo/osug/blousise. sarathecow ended up with 4.4k feed.

Code: Select all

(11:46 / Allied) Ollo: stop
(11:41 / Allied) blousise: wtf
(11:31 / Allied) osug: dont feed


In this case Titan was somewhat new, but that doesn't matter. These situations you either agree to feed or end it and move on. If this Titan were experienced or hiding their skill it would have definitely ruined the game so I think Sarathecow should be punished accordingly.

[sarathecow]

I'm sorry if I ruined the game-experience for you or anyone else.
It was not my intention, and I had the idéa that it was accepted to feed the Titan in general when he is that new and that far behind.
The game would have been over allot earlier, with a dead titan as the result if he was not fed.

I have read the rules earlier, although some of the specifics might be forgotten, I'll revisit them after this post.
I do however understand now that these things should be brought to a vote, and will refer from feeding unless agreed upon in the future games.

You could of course punish me, but it will serve as no lesson, as I've already learned it.

[osug]

Thank you for your message Sara and thank you for understanding.
This ban request is - of course - no offensive against you and I hope you won't take it personally.

In my opinion your apologize is fair and understandable, therefore there is no need to ban you. I hope to enjoy further games with you.


@mods
Since Sarathecow apologized and made clear he didn't wanted to ruin the game itself I don't think this brq is needed anymore.
Could one Mod please just close it?

[Hash]

Glad everything got worked out. Processed.