[DOTA] MaXXor and ShutUp USWest

[Tulkas]

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 675465.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA apem us/ca #34
Your Warcraft III Username: Mr_Darcy
Violator's Warcraft III Username: Maxxor; ShutUp2
Violated Rule(s):

Maxxor – excessive grieving with mass ping and votekick abuse
ShutUp - Refused to cooperate

Time of Violation (in-game or replay):

Here are instances of Maxxor mass ping and vk abuse:

(13:11 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: !timestamp
(13:13 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: mass ping
(38:21 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: !timestamp mass ping
(41:33 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: !timestamp mass ping
(45:38 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: !timestamp mass ping

(14:48 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(18:19 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(20:59 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(28:15 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(35:54 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(41:39 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(44:23 / All) tripz05: A votekick against player [ShutUp2] has been started by player [MaXXor]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.

And there are two instances when ShutUp was pushing solo instead of helping defend. This is debatable so I can understand if it's not ban worthy.
(38:25 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: !timestamp refusal
(50:51 / Allied) Mr_Darcy: slark refuses to defend

Any further thoughts:

Maxxor definitely deserves ban.

ShutUp seemed to blatantly refuse to help defend during two critical pushes. This is all the more aggravated by the fact we were playing 4v5 all game and could not defend w/out most if not all the team together. That being said, one could argue that he was taking advtange of enemy push to push base himself. It deserves a look at least, but I could be wrong if it's ban worthy.

[Astros]

maxxor banned 24 hrs for mass pinging. Already mass pinging 4 minutes into the game.


Not enough evidence to ban ShutUp. Denying this one.

Thanks for reporting.